As I read Leah Sottile’s exhaustive account of the birth and growth of the “New Age” movement in America, I occasionally had to put her book down so I could try to wrap my head around it all. Spiritualists claiming to channel ancient masters from the sunken continent of Lemuria. Hucksters and conmen spinning fantastical and ludicrous — and anti-semitic — yarns about America’s ills, and making a fortune while doing so. Acolytes who kept believing even after they were confronted with the most disturbing evidence of their teachers’ flaws and failings. To Sottile’s credit, though, I couldn’t stop reading. Blazing Eye Sees All is actually two books in one. Half of the book chronicles the rise and fall of Love Has Won, a cult started by a woman who, after abandoning her family, called herself Mother God and built a devoted following via social media. The other half chronicles the history of spiritualism and theosophy in America, including figures like the Fox sisters, Madame Blavatsky, and Guy and Edna Ballard, whose outlandish claims laid the foundation for Love Has Won. Sottile occasionally struggles to balance these two narratives. On the whole, however, Blazing Eye Sees All remains compelling, particularly when Sotille explores the appeal that such movements hold for women who often lack a sense of power or agency in their lives, or when she finds striking (and disturbing) parallels between the ultra-nationalist teachings of early 20th century spiritualists and the ultra-nationalist rhetoric of QAnon, January 6 insurrectionists, and other far-right factions. (On a side note, the reason this book caught my eye in the first place was because the title and cover art make it look like something an actual cult might publish. I can only assume that was intentional, and I applaud the decision.)