I’m not much of a podcast listener, but the promise of an in-depth exploration of the Satanic Panic was just too good to pass up. Now, if you didn’t grow up in the church during the ’80s and ’90s, then I don’t know if I can fully explain what it was like to believe that an underground cabal of Satanists was kidnapping, torturing, and sacrificing children all over the nation. That sounds outlandish now, I know, but it permeated the culture back then, giving rise to moral panics over heavy metal and Dungeons & Dragons, allowing grifters like Mike Warnke and Beatrice Sparks to turn a tidy profit, and upending countless lives over hearsay. Host Mike Cosper does yeoman’s work, teasing out the Panic’s origins stretching all the way back to Christian concerns over the ’60s counterculture. He explores its various manifestations and key events (like the McMartin preschool trial and the West Memphis Three) and considers its lingering influence on modern politics (e.g., Christian Nationalism, January 6, QAnon). Cosper casts a pretty wide net, and at times, the podcast’s episodes do meander as he goes down one rabbit trail or another. Still, the result is a fascinating — and troubling — account of a truly bizarre moment in American history that hasn’t really left us. More importantly, it’s a potent reminder (for Christians, especially) that the more obsessed we become with perceived evils “out there,” the blinder we’ll become to the very real evils in our own midst.