Darren Aronofsky is best-known for dark, nightmarish, and highly stylized films like Pi, Requiem For a Dream, and Black Swan. But Caught Stealing represents something of a shift for the acclaimed director: a comedy crime caper, albeit a really dark one replete with Russian gangsters and Hasidic drug dealers. Hank Thompson (Austin Butler) was an aspiring major league baseball player who now just tends bar in New York circa 1998. But when his punk rock neighbor (Matt Smith) asks him to cat sit for awhile, Hank gets caught up in a whirlwind of drug deals, stolen money, and the aforementioned villains. It’s all twist-y and turn-y, and Aronofsky is not shy with the bodily fluids as people get beat up, tortured, and shot. But to be honest, it’s surprisingly tepid. Based on the trailer, I was expecting something in the vein of a classic Guy Ritchie caper like Lock, Stock and Two Smoking Barrels or Snatch, but Caught Stealing never quite achieves that level of riotous energy. Butler is never anything less than watchable and the film’s evocation of the late ’90s is fun (flip phones everywhere!), but in the end, Caught Stealing is mostly forgettable — which is something you’d never think you’d say about a Darren Aronofsky film.